US manufacturing
Strong on both- Sticker Supply Co
- Printed in South Portland, Maine
- StickerGiant
- Printed in Longmont, Colorado
Two real US print teams, compared honestly
Sticker Supply Co vs StickerGiant
StickerGiant is the closest match in this group to Sticker Supply Co: it prints in Colorado, reviews files with real production artists, offers phone support, and has rush printing. The meaningful differences are geography, material specificity, packaging-fit service, custom sampling, specialty capabilities, and how far each team will go beyond the standard sticker-and-label menu.
Independently researched · Last reviewed September 3, 2026
The honest take
Both companies are credible choices for customers who value US production and human review. StickerGiant has scale, a long operating history, and a mature rush program. Sticker Supply Co offers a smaller-team relationship, Maine proximity, named high-tack vinyl options, free custom tests, packaging measurement, and more flexibility for one-off print work.
Feature by feature
How Sticker Supply Co and StickerGiant compare
The right choice depends on the job. Here is the practical difference across the factors that usually matter most.
Human proofing
Strong on both- Sticker Supply Co
- Professional local designer prepares every proof and print file
- StickerGiant
- Graphic Production Artist reviews each file and prepares a digital proof
Rush capability
Strong on both- Sticker Supply Co
- Rush orders coordinated directly around the real deadline
- StickerGiant
- Eligible orders can ship one business day after proof approval for a fee
Material specificity
Depends on the job- Sticker Supply Co
- Named General Formulations high-tack and other premium options
- StickerGiant
- Published material specifications by sticker and label product
Custom test samples
Sticker Supply edge- Sticker Supply Co
- Free custom test sample available whenever requested
- StickerGiant
- Material samples and low-quantity production options vary by product
Packaging measurement
Sticker Supply edge- Sticker Supply Co
- Customer can mail or bring packaging for hands-on measurement
- StickerGiant
- Support team helps customers choose products and specifications
Specialty and one-off work
Depends on the job- Sticker Supply Co
- UV and eco-solvent printing, embossing, white ink, canvas, and custom projects
- StickerGiant
- Deep sticker and label catalog, including specialty and backprinted products
Give credit where it is due
What StickerGiant does well
A useful comparison should make the competitor's case too. These are meaningful strengths—not straw men.
- In-house production in Longmont, Colorado since 2000
- Every file reviewed by a Graphic Production Artist with a digital proof
- Published rush option that ships eligible work one business day after proof approval
- Colorado-based phone, email, and chat support
A small-team relationship
You can call and speak directly with our South Portland team about the proof, material, press, deadline, and application. We stay close to the work because the team is intentionally small.
Specific premium vinyl options
We offer General Formulations high-tack permanent adhesive vinyl and can explain exactly why a material fits—or does not fit—the surface and environment.
A packaging-fit service
Browse labels by packaging type, then mail or bring us the container if you want our team to measure it and help confirm the size.
More room for the unusual
Eco-solvent and UV printing, embossing, white ink layers, canvas, affordable design, and niche one-off projects give us more ways to solve the whole job.
Match the printer to the project
Three questions that make the choice easier
Do you need a formal next-business-day production option?
StickerGiant publishes a clear paid rush program for eligible products. Sticker Supply Co also accepts rush work, but confirms feasibility directly based on the job and deadline.
Are you in Maine or New England?
Sticker Supply Co offers the local advantage, including direct access to the South Portland shop and team.
Does the job require testing, measuring, design, or nonstandard finishing?
Sticker Supply Co is the stronger fit for an open-ended project because custom tests, packaging measurement, design services, and one-off production are part of the way the shop works.
South Portland, Maine
What every order gets from us
These are not premium support tiers. They are how our small team handles everyday work.
Proof prepared by a professional local designer
Internal quality checks before the order ships
Free extra stickers included in typical runs
Direct access to a real person on our team
Reprint-or-refund full guarantee
High-end Roland printers and Roland-brand inks
Questions, answered
Sticker Supply Co vs StickerGiant FAQ
Is Sticker Supply Co a good alternative to StickerGiant?+
Yes. Both are US print operations with human artwork review and rush capabilities. Sticker Supply Co is a particularly strong alternative for Maine and New England businesses or projects needing specific high-tack materials, custom testing, packaging measurement, and specialty work.
Does StickerGiant use real people for proofs?+
Yes. StickerGiant states that Graphic Production Artists review files and prepare digital proofs. Sticker Supply Co also uses people, with local professional graphic designers preparing every proof and production file before the customer review.
Which company is faster?+
StickerGiant advertises a paid rush option that ships eligible products one business day after proof approval. Sticker Supply Co accepts rush orders and works directly with customers to plan around the actual product, proof, pickup or shipping destination, and deadline.
What is the biggest difference between Sticker Supply Co and StickerGiant?+
The biggest difference is the type of relationship and project scope. Sticker Supply Co is a smaller Maine team that combines sticker and label printing with packaging measurement, design, custom test samples, named specialty vinyl, UV and eco-solvent work, embossing, canvas, and niche one-off projects.
Research notes and sources
Competitor information was checked against the public pages below on September 3, 2026. Products, prices, policies, and turnaround can change, so confirm time-sensitive details before ordering.
- StickerGiant — Custom sticker printing
- StickerGiant — About its Colorado operation
- StickerGiant — Proof review process
- StickerGiant — Rush printing
StickerGiant is a trademark of its respective owner. Sticker Supply Co is not affiliated with or endorsed by StickerGiant. This page is an informational comparison based on publicly available information and our own service practices.
Still deciding? Send us the real job.
Tell us the surface, quantity, deadline, and what matters most. We will recommend the material and process we would use—before you commit.